April 2004Issue 366



Hook noses and harems

Hollywood thrillers have a lot to answer for, feels Reem Haddad.

Sarah John

I CAN tell immediately. If an Arab appears in an action movie then you can be almost certain that he will be a terrorist. If the movie is set in the Middle East, then the local people must be backward – and unattractive. Without fail. I automatically switch the channel. Now, more than ever, Arabs are being portrayed as ignorant and brutal.

As for Beirut, according to Hollywood, it is a bullet-ridden city where militants run around freely and where Hizbullah fighters roam the streets threatening citizens. Never mind that the civil war ended 13 years ago and the city has been rebuilt.

Even in cartoons, Arabs are the ‘bad’ guys who kidnap the heroines. Remember Disney’s Aladdin? The opening song depicted the Arab world as ‘a faraway place, where the caravan camels roam, where they cut off your ear if they don’t like your face. It’s barbaric but hey it’s home.’ It took a lot of work from American-Arab anti-discrimination activists in the US to change some of the lyrics for the video version.

And of course such stereotypes inform real life, too. I remember when, fl eeing from the Lebanese civil war, we went to the US in the late 1980s and I enrolled in the local high school just outside Washington DC. On a tour of the school, my student guide planted me in front of a television set and said rather loudly: ‘This is a TELEVISION, we watch moving pictures on it.’

A few days later, curious students asked me how my father managed his camels and oil wells and did I know what a church was. I think if I were to meet them now, they would ask me where my father’s terrorist cells are.

Of course, if you see nothing different in popular movies, then it’s hard to shake off such ignorance. Physically, Arab men are portrayed with unshaven beards, long noses, head kaffiyas and dirty clothes. Women are seen draped in black clothes with tight headscarves and submissive to men. Unless, of course, they’re living in a harem.

At one point during my university years in the US, posters were hung up advertising a deodorant. It depicted a man with a long nose and dirty head garment. ‘Don’t smell like an Arab,’ it said. ‘Use a deodorant.’

Friends have reported similar stories. During her stay at a Western university, Rania – who has blond hair and blue eyes – was told by administrators that she blended in well in the campus as she didn’t ‘look like an Arab’.

Jack Shaheen, author of Reel Bad Arabs, has sat through more than enough films with such offensive stereotypes. In an interview with Beirut’s Daily Star, he said that he could count over 900 films which project Arabs as villains. Among the terms used to refer to them are ‘rag-heads’, ‘towel-heads’, ‘sons-ofshe- camels’, ‘son-of-an-unnamed-goat’ and ‘camel-dicks’.

Arabs trying to rape or abduct Western heroines appear in more than 20 films. Arabs enslaving Africans feature in about 10 and at least 11 Israeli-made films portray Americans and/or Israelis killing ‘evil Arabs’.

Anti-Christian Arabs feature in more than 20 films. As for Christian Arabs, they seem to be non-existent. For Hollywood, Arabs are automatically Muslim.

Of the 43 fiction films examined by Shaheen that involved Palestinian characters, more than half were filmed in Israel between 1983 and 1998, including the blockbusters True Lies, The Siege, and Delta Force – all of which pitted Palestinian terrorists against American heroes.

Unfortunately, such movies only fuel Arab anger and deepen the Israeli-Arab divide.

But as Shaheen says: ‘The Arab stereotype is easy. It makes money. Filmmakers grow up with the stereotypes and so revert to them easily.’

Reem Haddad works for the Daily Star in Beirut.




also by...
THIS AUTHOR

In hope of justice
In this, Reem Haddad’s last Letter from Lebanon, she reflects on the aftershocks of an attack which has seared her country’s soul. In the next issue we begin a new series – Letter from Mauritius.

Breaking silence
A reality television show has shattered an age-old taboo for Arab women. Reem Haddad finds opinions divided.

Yesterday's men
In the thick of the convoluted Lebanese elections, Reem Haddad can’t believe her eyes or her ears.

A test of wills
Explosions rock Reem Haddad’s beloved Beirut – and out of the cave of fear, new-found courage emerges.

Language Tools
Powered by Ultralingua

Join over 30,000 people just like you. Get e-mail updates about new content, action alerts, contests, and more!

other articles
FROM THIS ISSUE

Hungarian soufflé
Alex Bandy draws up a balance sheet of winners and losers as Hungary knocks on the door of the European Union.

Shafiqul Alam Kiron
The infinite joy of childhood, by Bangladeshi photographer Shafiqul Alam Kiron.

Re-inventing Russian socialism
An interview from Moscow with Boris Kagarlitsky.

Profile of Eloísa Cartonera
The ultimate poor person’s publisher profiled: Eloísa Cartonera from Argentina.

Polyp's Big Bad World – April 2004
Global warming: 'a matter of opinion'.

recently
IN THIS COLUMN

Permission denied
Maria Golia recalls why part of her Egyptian education involved learning how to break the rules.

Wealth in abundance
'Make do and mend' is a time-honoured Egyptian talent, discovers Maria Golia.

Turning Japanese
Maria Golia recalls a moment of cultural confusion.

Shake and sway
Maria Golia ponders Egypt’s attitude towards sexuality.

Making room
Even when the odds are stacked against them, Maria Golia observes her neighbour’s family taking life as it comes.

Friday fracas
Maria Golia goes into battle for the underdog – and then wonders just what she has done.






Voices from the margins:

Multimedia: video, podcasts, and more.


Subscribe to NI now!