July 2007Issue 402


Lesbian and unprivileged

Loving Women – Being Lesbian and Unprivileged in India

A journey through lesbian working-class India

‘You ask me if I have heard the word “lesbian”. No, I have not heard it,” says factory worker Vimlesh, one of the women interviewed by Maya Sharma in this extraordinary book. Vimlesh continues: ‘I am attracted to women. Why create these categories, such deep differences between male and female? We are all human beings, aren’t we?’

‘Groundbreaking’ is an over-used epithet, but in the case of this journey through lesbian working-class India it is entirely warranted. The movement for lesbian rights that has emerged in the country during the past decade has been predominantly privileged. Only women who can afford to live independently of tight family networks and the enforcements of tradition can live as lesbians. As for the women-who-love-women in shanty towns and villages, who knows who they are or how they live or even whether they exist?

With patience, determination and sensitivity, Maya Sharma has managed to make contact and get to know these ‘invisible’ women; the stories with which they slowly entrust her make for compelling and moving reading. These are powerful testimonies of love, courage, despair, accommodation, violence, endurance, passion, prejudice and rebellion. There are surprises aplenty, and ingenuity too; with little or no access to the ‘movement’, the women have to navigate their way around compulsory heterosexual marriage, stultifying patriarchal tradition and the omnipresent threat of violence. Some interviewees are fiercely memorable. Juhi, for example, who says: ‘It’s a blessing to have daughters. I did not want sons, I know what men are all about. All my daughters are lesbians. Oh yes! I know the word lesbian. So do my daughters.’

Product information
by Maya Sharma
Star rating
*****
Publisher
Yoda Press

Vanessa Baird




also by...
THIS AUTHOR

Trafficked
Behind the doors of ordinary-seeming flats, houses, hotels, a brutal form of modern slavery is taking place. And it’s happening worldwide. Vanessa Baird wonders why – and what can be done about it.

Stop Traffick!
A global selection of some of the more progressive, inventive and even unusual initiatives that have been launched to tackle trafficking...

Sex trafficking – the facts
Trafficking for sexual exploitation has become an epidemic in the past decade.

Anatomy of a scam
John Githongo, Kenya’s exiled anti- corruption chief, speaks to Vanessa Baird.

Language Tools
Powered by Ultralingua

Join over 10,000 people just like you. Get e-mail updates about new content, issue alerts, contests, and more!

other articles
FROM THIS ISSUE

Burundi
A small landlocked state in central Africa, sandwiched between its vast neighbours Tanzania and Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi has suffered as much from ethnic conflict as its other (equally tiny) neighbour, Rwanda. Yet while the 1993 Rwandan genocide continues to commandeer international attention, Burundi’s travails tend to slip under the radar.

Of robbers and plants
Economic crunch in Mauritius

Edible Earth
In search of bright ideas, David Ransom begins by learning some very basic lessons about how to design a more sustainable, permanent culture.

The ethical heart of permaculture
Maddy Harland outlines the principles that make it beat.

The Islamophobia debate
When is it fair to criticize Islam and when is it not?

recently
IN THIS COLUMN

The Guantánamo Files
The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison

Nobody’s Home
Ugresic’s new collection of essays

Another production is possible
by Boaventura de Sousa Santos (ed)

Girls of Riyadh
by Rajaa Alsanea

The Shock Doctrine
The Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein

Hold Everything Dear – Dispatches on Survival and Resistance
Hold Everything Dear – Dispatches on Survival and Resistance by John Berger






Voices from the margins:

Multimedia: video, podcasts, and more.