August 2008Issue 414



Body Shopping: The Economy Fuelled by Flesh and Blood

by Donna Dickensen

Product information
(One World, ISBN 9781851685912)
Star rating
***

Body Shopping

Donna Dickensen’s fascinating overview of the complex world of medical ethics begins with the seemingly simple question: ‘Do we own our own bodies?’ From the answer given by the legal world – a pretty unequivocal ‘No’ – flows much philosophical and commercial wrangling, with individual rights pitted against state and corporate might. Drawing on examples such as the US Supreme Court’s decision that John Moore, whose spleen was removed and used in research, had no claim on any of the profits that research generated, Dickensen demonstrates that, time and again, legal logic-chopping is used to prioritize commercial interests over ethical or, indeed, humanitarian concerns.

Dickensen covers much territory in this short book – from the global scandal that is ‘egg harvesting’ in which desperate women from poor communities are turned into ovulating factories, to the huge profits generated by umbilical cord blood banks. She presents a chilling world in which the human body is no more than a collection of raw material for lucrative bio-engineered products: a technological equivalent of the 18th-century Enclosure Acts that appropriates our ‘genetic commons’. She acknowledges that there are influential voices who welcome such developments, such as the French author Herve Juvin, who recasts the 1960s feminist slogan ‘Our bodies, ourselves’ as ‘My body, my capital’, viewing flesh and bone, organs and genes as material assets, just like any other. Body Shopping is a welcome and timely rallying cry for those who find such enthusiastic commodification of the human body to be both reductive and repugnant.

PW




also by...
THIS AUTHOR

Taxi
by Khaled Al Khamissi
translated from Arabic by Jonathan Wright

Beijing Coma
Written by Ma Jian
Translated by Flora Drew

Final Silence

The Rich Man of Pietermaritzburg

Language Tools
Powered by Ultralingua

Join over 10,000 people just like you. Get e-mail updates about new content, issue alerts, contests, and more!

other articles
FROM THIS ISSUE

The pen is messier than the sword
Maria Golia explains why the pen is messier than the sword in her Letter from Cairo.

Stand up, stand up for toilets...
Toilet champions are not so rare a breed as you’d think. Here are some distinguished exemplars.

To Sewer or Not to Sewer
David Satterthwaite speaks out in praise of sewers, and Mayling Simpson-Hébert retaliates on behalf of pits.

Letter to Anna: the Story of Journalist Politkovskaya’s Death
The story of one journalist who tirelessly exposed its horrors and manipulation by the Moscow political class.

Technofixes: climate solution or corporate scam?
Science is coming up with ever more extraordinary proposals for combating climate change, from laying white plastic over deserts to locking up carbon dioxide in the oceans or shooting it into space. Should we take any of this seriously?

recently
IN THIS COLUMN

From A to X: A Story in Letters
A heartrending love-story and a searing indictment of authoritarianism in all its forms.

The Rebels' Hour
Lieve Joris's spellbinding account of the recent ill-starred history of the Democratic Republic of Congo.

The Riddle of Qaf
The Riddle of Qaf is crammed with allusions to classical literature and cod-scientific theories and it makes free (and unapologetic) use of myths and legends.

Dancing, dying, crawling, crying
Stories of continuity and change in the Polynesian community of Tikopia by Julian Treadaway

In Defense of Lost Causes
Superstar philosopher Slavoj Zizek writes in defence of lost causes

Children of the Revolution
This is a book that highlights how people caught in between places are denied identity, perspective and intimacy.