April 2003 • Issue 355


Privatization / Fightback - No pain, all gain

No pain, all gain

Big companies are happy to collect profits in newly privatized markets but they prefer the public to cover the risks: political instability and popular resistance. Remarkably, pliant governments are happy to oblige. One of their favorite tools for subsidizing corporate investments in the developing world is the export credit agency (ECA).

ECAs are public institutions that provide insurance, loans and loan guarantees to companies expanding into ‘emerging markets’. The G7 industrialized nations all have at least one ECA. Together, the agencies supported more than $390 billion in private-sector investment in 1998. They are, in the words of one supporter, ‘the unsung giants of international trade and finance’.

Many international financial institutions – like the World Bank – disguise their operations under the cloak of ‘poverty reduction’. But not export credit agencies. Their goal is simple – to make sure that companies based in the ECA’s home country thrive overseas. Yet ECAs work in tandem with the World Bank and others. As Aaron Goldzimer of the Environmental Defense Fund explains, the World Bank, the IMF and the WTO ‘open countries up with the trade and economic policies that they impose’ while ‘ECAs provide the direct finance and cover for corporations to invest’.

German, Japanese, US and Italian ECAs played important roles in privatizing portions of Bolivia’s state oil company. Their financing of pipeline projects – over $650 million since 1997 – benefited Enron and Shell while endangering Bolivia’s ecologically sensitive Pantanal region, the world’s largest remaining wetland.

Besides directly underwriting privatization, ECAs make possible some of the dirtiest deals of corporate globalization – including projects that even the World Bank won’t touch. ECAs finance 14 of 19 nuclear-power plants currently under construction in the developing world. Over the years, more than 30 per cent of the guarantees provided by ECAs in France and Britain have served to finance arms sales. And, despite being slammed as an environmental disaster, construction on China’s massive Three Gorges Dam moves forward – thanks mainly to export credit contributions from countries like Canada, Germany, Sweden and Switzerland.

Responding to these abuses, 347 civil-society groups from 50 countries endorsed the Jakarta Declaration in May 2000. The statement calls for cancellation of the huge portion of the developing world’s foreign debt held by ECAs. It insists upon binding environmental, social and human-rights guidelines. And it demands that ECAs adopt transparent procedures to end the secrecy that has hidden many deals from public scrutiny.

Since Jakarta, activists have moved to link their campaigns internationally – with some success. Recently, the construction of the Ilisu Dam in Turkey was stopped. The Dam would have displaced 78,000 people, mostly ethnic Kurds.

If this movement continues to grow, unchecked public financing for corporate expansion may become a thing of the past – a development that would leave privatization with an uncertain future.

Mark Engler is a regular contributor to the NI. He is based in New York City. For information about national export credit campaigns see: http://www.eca-watch.org/about/members.html




also by...
THIS AUTHOR

Sweating over sweatshops
Supporting ‘clean clothes’ campaigns to end the extreme exploitation that pervades the textile industry is not as simple as just picking the ‘right’ brand to buy, reveals Mark Engler.

Truth and Fantasy
Twisting history to suit the moment is something the Bush Administration does without shame. Mark Engler looks at how El Salvador’s historic Truth Commission Report has once again become a living document.

No prescription needed
Work with us, don’t just criticize, said the World Bank President. But when his joint review with the SAPRIN network showed the failure of Bank-imposed policies, he bailed out, as Mark Engler reports.

Yes we can!
Mark Engler argues that immigrant-driven campaigns at the grassroots plus a dose of ‘new internationalism’ are key to reviving the US labor movement.

Language Tools
Powered by Ultralingua

Join over 10,000 people just like you. Get e-mail updates about new content, issue alerts, contests, and more!

other articles
FROM THIS ISSUE

Bad Medicine
Britain’s vaunted National Health Service is reeling, hammered by lack of funding and government bumbling. But privatizing the system is not the answer, argues Allyson Pollock. GATS Attacks!

I shop, therefore I am
Has the narcissism of the market destroyed our sense of collective identity? Psychiatrist Trevor Turner argues that a preoccupation with self has spawned a new syndrome: malignant self-actualization.

Gats Attacks
Evil invaders from another planet blast our precious public services. Illustration by Polyp.

The new apartheid
South Africa’s trade unions loudly oppose the Government’s sell-off of basic services. But the ANC isn’t listening, warns Patrick Bond.

The Great Privatization Grab
Like modern-day pirates, marauding corporations are hijacking our public services – while governments turn a blind eye. Wayne Ellwood debunks the privatization myth.

recently
IN THIS COLUMN

Human rights - the facts
Human rights refer not just to personal civil and political rights, but collective economic, social and cultural ones too. Worldwide, they are more violated than respected.

Breathless in Beijing
Sam Geall reports on broken promises at the Olympics.

Who killed Maksim Maksimov?
Not that no-one knows. Maria Yulikova reports on the brutal assassination of a journalist in Russia.

A guide through the maze
The Declarations, Covenants and Conventions that make up the International Bill of Rights.

Off the buses
The Syndicate of Workers of Tehran and Suburbs Bus Company (Sherkat-e Vahed).

The eternal minority
The Roma – still widely known as ‘Gypsies’ – have had a raw deal for centuries and are only now starting to raise their voice on the international stage. Eleanor Harding looks at their plight in Romania, while the NI traces their history back to India.






Voices from the margins:

Multimedia: video, podcasts, and more.

House of Hunger Poetry Slam in Zimbabwe
Poetry Slam in Zimbabwe
The House of Hunger poetry slam held in Zimbabwe in 2006, and organised by the Pamberi Trust, showcased young artists performing inspirational work on issues from corporate power to child soldiers. The video features four of the poets.
Published by Pambazuka News.
Raised Voices video:
Atossa Soltani from Brazil on the Climate Change
Desmond Desai from South Africa on Corporate Power
Iranian Women Speak Out
Iranian women speak out
3 March 2007, London. Women's rights activists marched through the English capital last week to celebrate International Women's Day with a protest against the misogyny of the Islamic regime in Iran and the threat of invasion by the US. Hear the voices of Iranian feminists Azar and Leila Parnian and the sounds of the demonstration as it passed through the heart of the city. Click here to learn more about the campaign.
Produced by Heidi Bachram.
Raised Voices audio:
Benny from West Papua on Corporate Power
Vinayan from India on agriculture