new internationalist
issue 189 - November 1988
the
West's
debt to the
Third World
In the West we readily accept the idea of Third World debt
and forget that our present wealth has been built on riches plundered
by our colonizing ancestors. NI takes a broader, historical look at
debt and asks 'Who owes what to whom?'
Pioneer European settlers used several methods to take land
from indigenous people. In Aotearoa (NZ) the concept that land could
be possessed was entirely foreign to Maori thinking. This enabled
settlers to buy land from them at ridiculously low prices. In Australia,
Canada and the Americas, killing native people was the method usually
favoured by settlers. Later European governments got in on the act
and set about invading and colonising large chunks of the globe. Vast
territories were turned over to growing cash crops and extracting
minerals for Western interests. Today ex-colonies remain locked into
these impoverishing patterns of land use and borrowing money is often
their only way to survive.
|
European colonizers also sought raw materials like gold, diamonds
and timber. King Sugar had accrued massive wealth in Europe which
generated the scientific and technological innovations that led to
the industrial revolution. As technology progressed the hunger for
raw materials grew. In 1885 seven European powers invaded Africa for
their share of what King Leopold of Belgium described as 'this magnificent
African cake'. Today many Third World countries remain dependent on
selling their commodities to the West. But the West has manufactured
substitutes and commodity prices have crashed - making it increasingly
hard for Third World countries to earn enough to repay their debts.
|
The colonists soon had plenty of land and a labour force was
needed. They devised a simple solution to this problem : the slave
trade. Around twelve million Africans were captured and transported
to work the cotton field and sugar plantations of the Caribbean and
North America. Later in India and Africa whole villages rounded up
and forced to work for minimal wages set by foreign officials. Resistance
was met by beatings, fines or imprisonment. Unions were forbidden.
It can be argued that forced labour has not ceased but merely changed
its form.
The fall in commodity prices means that Third World
countries must produce more to earn the same amount. This has to be
spent on repaying debts to the rich world: the fear of no more loans
keeps them in line. High costs, low wages and merciless poverty are
the price that Third World people pay.
|
In order to kill and enslave indigenous peoples, Europeans
had to believe their victims were sub-human. The history, culture
and knowledge of these people were denigrated and the contributions
they had made to European thought forgotten. When the settlers of
Canada and North America took Indian land, they conveniently ignored
that the Indians had taught them how to cook local foods and prepare
herbal medicines. And when racism exploded in the eighteenth century
- to justify slavery - it wiped out any acknowledgement of African
achievements. The history of mathematics - long held by the Classical
Greeks to have originated from Ancient Egypt - was swept under the
academic carpet and lost. This ignorance continues today, reinforcing
racism and giving an ideological justification for the idea of 'Third
World debt'.
|
European settlers got the best of both worlds. Not only did
they steal land, labour and raw materials from native peoples: they
sold European goods to them as well. In North America and Canada,
they swapped iron pots, tools and guns with Indians for furs and food.
And later, they traded guns and other manufactured goods with rich
Africans in exchange for slaves. Third World markets provided outlets
for manufactured products, enabling the growth of Western industry.
And developing countries continue to buy Western goods and services
- often with Western loans - for ill-conceived development projects
recommended by Western 'experts'.
|
Finally
colonizing nations discovered more direct ways of profiting from
Third World peoples: they simply demanded money from them. The British
introduced a system of taxation in Africa which forced the Africans
to work for their colonizers simply to pay their taxes. In the same
way, the West continues to make large sums of money from Third World
debt. Loans frequently come straight back to us from the purchase
of Western goods. We buy Third World commodities for a song. And we
receive a steady income from interest on Third World debts. So who
owes what to whom?
|




