![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| NEW INTERNATIONALIST 202 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
| THIS MONTH'S THEME | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Captives
of Design Four ears,
six hands
Lost in
(planned) space The shape
of change Malldom Towers
of the new gods Poverty
and Pride Simply .how to judge architecture A woman's
place They
paved paradise |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
ARCHITECTURE |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| FROM THIS MONTH'S EDITOR | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
It makes a big difference to have someone like Fred to greet you when you go out for the Globe and Mail in the morning or come back from the Toronto NI office after a long day of listening to subscribers' complaints about late magazines. It is hard to imagine Fred living in an anonymous high-rise apartment or even a standard suburban house without his conviviality withering away. In some strange way the buildings where we live and work have a role in shaping us. They reinforce some of our proclivities and frustrate others: self-absorption or an openness to other people; frenetic activity or a more contemplative approach to the world. But while architecture is important to the quality of our lives it is a subject I tackle hesitantly. The hesitancy stems from entering a specialized world of strongly held views. I find it much clearer to take a stand on something overtly political than something so dependent on personal taste. Why are my tastes any more valid than someone else's? That said, I hold very strong views about the wall of concrete that separates Toronto from its lakefront - or about the sacrifice of historic city centres on the altar of the automobile. But unlike Prince Charles I cannot bring myself to blame these things on architects. The architects I know, I like a lot. They tend to be obsessive and idealistic. Ideas matter to them. They are mostly poor and lack the confident self-satisfaction that is so irritating in other professionals. If they are sometimes guilty of arrogance it is because, as one architect put it to me recently, 'you have to be arrogant if you believe in a design. You have to overcome the commercial prejudices of developers, the pettiness of planners and everyone else who thinks they know better than you'. I could understand the point but also see its dangers. It assumes the best of intentions on the part of the architect when inevitably some of them are hacks and others are despots. The NI strives to be a popular magazine - to make its exploration of a subject as lively and entertaining as possible. I believe in this ideal. As a reader myself I know that on a lot of subjects I want a colourful and coherent overview with the occasional outburst of pure opinion. Yet as an editor there is always a danger of getting so immersed in the subject at hand that you reproduce the language and ways of seeing that are the currency of tomes on world finance - or in this case architectural journals. On the other hand in striving to popularize you run the risk of losing credibility. I fear that most dreaded of comebacks from someone who has intimate knowledge of the subject: 'if you are this wrong on something I really know about, how can I trust you on the things of which I have no knowledge?' There should be a creative tension between popularizing a subject and putting a well-thought-out interpretation on the facts. The balance needs to be right or one risks yawns at the one extreme or simple dismissal at the other. But I don't mind provoking disagreement. And I have a feeling that on something as subjective as architecture I be pretty sure of achieving at least this. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Richard Swift for the New Internationalist Co-operative |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Letters
COVER ILLUSTRATION: Hector Cattolica |
|||||||||||||||||||||||




Fred
lives in the same housing co-op as I do. Rain or shine he hangs out in the
grass courtyard around which the two- and three-storey brick dwellings are
clustered. Fred always has a hello, a helping hand or a quick weather forecast
for any of his neighbours. He is like a quiet version of the old towncryer
- bringing greetings, neighbourhood news and advice.
