Decline
and fall
To describe Joseph Schumpeter as a
'conservative economic historian' (Keynote, West goes East: Life after
Communism,
NI 366) is quite simplistic, if not misleading.
Schumpeter's main concern was the analysis of change in capitalist systems. His
theory of 'creative destruction', used in the article to describe the economic
and social upheavals of transforming the former communist bloc countries into
capitalist economies, is in reality a concept examining the rise and, crucially,
the decline of capitalism. Moreover, Schumpeter thought that Marx was right in
believing that socialism
would replace capitalism because 'creative
destruction' will strengthen it only in the short term. In the long run the successes
of
capitalism will turn into failures and lead to
its downfall.
Holger
Kroll
Cardiff, Wales

A
right stink
Once again, the long-suffering, little people
of Eastern Europe have been used as doormats
by the 'first up, best dressed' brigade and real democracy remains as illusory
as ever. Even Blind Freddy can see that the transition from communism to capitalism
should have been driven by small business with the vast privatization of public
assets
done slowly and incrementally to minimize
windfall profits to criminals.
When
the real history of the transition is
written, the world's main financial institutions will be seen to have acted
as little
more than money launderers in the vast
dispossession of the people's assets in Eastern Europe. Forget terrorism, the
real enemy of peace, civilization, humanity and justice is the world of high
(as in 'on the
nose') finance.
Tony
Hosking
Nakara, Australia

Film
stereotypes
I support Reem Haddad's decrying of cinematic stereotypes of
Arabs (Letter from Lebanon, NI
366) but it should be pointed
out that American films shot in Israel are not the same thing
as Israeli-made movies. In fact, most Israeli filmmakers depict
Israeli Arabs and Palestinians in complex, nuanced and sympathetic
ways. That's a distinct contrast to the common antisemitic and
stereotypical portrayal of Israelis and Jews in Arab films and
television, such as in the recent TV series based on the notorious
antisemitic
forgery, The Protocols of the Elders of Zion.
Shlomo
Schwartzberg
Toronto, Canada

Lazy
generalization
I have to express my dismay about the
sweeping generalization cast upon the
teaching profession by Siegrun Maybole
(Letters, NI 366). I am a teacher and have
never told a pupil that they were 'lazy, ignorant,
stupid etc' and neither would the vast
majority of my colleagues.
We
work hard at a job many people do not care to do yet everybody
has an opinion about. It is sometimes a thankless task when government
officials decide to poke about in something they rarely know
anything about.
In
accusing teachers of being the main barrier to learning you are
criticizing a worldwide profession whose intentions are to encourage
everyone to achieve all that
they are capable of.
Adam
Sutcliffe
Shetland, Scotland

Winter
veg
I was surprised to read the letter (NI
366)
claiming that there are no local fruits and
vegetables in winter in Winnipeg. This is a
falsehood perpetuated by a profit-hungry
food distribution system that insists on trucking
food as far as possible before it is bought.
I suggest that the writer please seek out local
farmers (like my brother) who grow root vegetables
and fruits that store well. (As a former
Manitoban, I dearly miss Saskatoons!)
Yes
it is sad that Coca-Cola is cheaper than milk for northern Canadians,
especially since the sugar was probably shipped farther than
the milk was! Again, our media/ culture has duped us. Instead
of drinking Florida orange juice, we make and bottle our own
sumac juice for the winter: local,
nutritious and free!
Timothy
Dyck
Durham, Canada

Homeopathic
dupes
Re Gurmej Virk's letter (NI
366). 'Our populations are unhealthier
than ever and the
diseases that plague us are more serious' compared to 100 years ago? Really?
When
one in every three children born died of
disease in childhood?
Big
Pharma would love an effective medicine that could be produced
for next to nothing; it would greatly increase profit margins.
Homeopathy is 'discredited', by health departments, doctors and
scientists, not because of any opposition by Big Pharma, but
because there has never been
any evidence that it has 'cured' anything. Yet charlatans continue to profit
from selling it. Yes, you did leave something out of your Big Pharma issue (NI
362) - the massive profits Big (and Small) Pharma makes from the unregulated
sale of homeopathic and
other 'alternative' medicine which does no
good and much harm.
Peter
Kennedy pharmacist,
Sydney, Australia

A
modest proposal
Congratulations on Adam Ma'anit's 'Imagine
That!' article (More World, Less Bank, NI 365). Allow me to append a suggestion:
People through a World Social Forum (WSF) should not only decommission the IMF/
World Bank and cancel all debts, personal, corporate and national, but investigate
ways to replace our troublesome money
economy with a social economy.
Let
me suggest that this WSF should mandate all computer manufacturers
along with their software companies, all producers of munitions
and war machines, as well as production of all minerals and other
raw materials. These form the basis for a new social economy
and should be publicly
controlled.
Is
it at all possible to imagine this: a care
and share economy?
Ken
Muma
London, Canada

Lithuania
on the up
The reports in West goes East (NI
366)
covered some of the worst countries in Eastern Europe and reflect
the
dismal state of conditions
that I have met in my travels in these sad places. But the
issue tended to give the impression that the whole region is a failure. I have
lived and worked in Lithuania since 1991 and the progress in
the Baltic States is miraculous. After independence little
happened for three years. Then we had a period of cosmetic improvement, but during
the last five years development has been really solid. Lithuania
has a growth rate of about 7 per cent,
pollution is well under control, old towns are being beautifully restored and
new supermarkets, shops and restaurants open daily. Taxes are
being effectively collected and corruption is greatly
reduced. Average salaries are about 30 Euros a day and morale is steadily rising.
Roderick
Tuck
Kaunas,
Lithuania.

HAVE
YOUR SAY
If you have ideas for topics that you'd like to read about in the NI next
year, why don't you let us know? Send your ideas to Dinyar Godrej by
21 June 2004, email: dinyar@antenna.nl
|

Wage gap
The recent Equality issue (NI
364) told
us how women in Australia earn on average
30 per cent less than men (Facts).
The average wage gap tells us very little,
for it fails to take into account important
factors such as age, education, consecutive
years of experience, and type of job.
When these factors are considered, women
and men in Australia earn about the
same (of course there is much to be done
to redress the appalling inequalities
around the globe). Interestingly you neglected
to mention that in every country
except Bangladesh, men's life expectancy
is considerably less than women's (in Australia by 6 years). I suspect most men
would happily take a 30-per-cent pay cut
in order to live 6 years longer!
Greg
Andresen
Henley Beach, Australia

Phony
co-ops
Your article 'Sugar daddies' (The sugar trap, NI
363) on how
sugarcane production has fuelled political corruption in some
states of India left a sour taste. To me these are phony co-operatives
and they bring shame on the international co-operative community.
A true co-operative is guided by basic principles. The first
principle, clearly breached in the Ambejogai cooperative, refers
to open and voluntary
membership - a co-operative is open to all, regardless of political affiliation,
and should not be used as a political fiefdom. Second, democratic ownership and
control should be in the hands of the members, not one family. Third, economic
participation - members should benefit economically and this was clearly not
the case for Uttam Siserao, who worked for free in the 2001-02 season. Finally
a cooperative
should be autonomous - and
not run by politicians or 'those who have
no stake in it at all'. Has the International Co-operative Alliance (www.ica.coop)
no
power or influence over these so-called
co-operatives?
Kate
Whittle
Shrewsbury, England

WOMEN'S
RIGHTS
The NI is doing a magazine on
women's rights which will look at what has changed for women since the UN Conference
on women in Beijing in 1995. We are seeking short comments, thoughts and ideas
from
readers - both male and female - about the changes there have been and what still
needs to happen.
Please email: nikkivdg@newint.org by
31 July 2004. |
