Click here to subscribe to the print edition.New Internationalist 368June 2004Click here to search the mega index.

Letters

Decline and fall
To describe Joseph Schumpeter as a 'conservative economic historian' (Keynote, West goes East: Life after Communism, NI 366) is quite simplistic, if not misleading. Schumpeter's main concern was the analysis of change in capitalist systems. His theory of 'creative destruction', used in the article to describe the economic and social upheavals of transforming the former communist bloc countries into capitalist economies, is in reality a concept examining the rise and, crucially, the decline of capitalism. Moreover, Schumpeter thought that Marx was right in believing that socialism would replace capitalism because 'creative destruction' will strengthen it only in the short term. In the long run the successes of capitalism will turn into failures and lead to its downfall.

West goes East: Life after Communism

Holger Kroll
Cardiff, Wales

A right stink
Once again, the long-suffering, little people of Eastern Europe have been used as doormats by the 'first up, best dressed' brigade and real democracy remains as illusory as ever. Even Blind Freddy can see that the transition from communism to capitalism should have been driven by small business with the vast privatization of public assets done slowly and incrementally to minimize windfall profits to criminals.

When the real history of the transition is written, the world's main financial institutions will be seen to have acted as little more than money launderers in the vast dispossession of the people's assets in Eastern Europe. Forget terrorism, the real enemy of peace, civilization, humanity and justice is the world of high (as in 'on the nose') finance.

Tony Hosking
Nakara, Australia

Film stereotypes
I support Reem Haddad's decrying of cinematic stereotypes of Arabs (Letter from Lebanon, NI 366) but it should be pointed out that American films shot in Israel are not the same thing as Israeli-made movies. In fact, most Israeli filmmakers depict Israeli Arabs and Palestinians in complex, nuanced and sympathetic ways. That's a distinct contrast to the common antisemitic and stereotypical portrayal of Israelis and Jews in Arab films and television, such as in the recent TV series based on the notorious antisemitic forgery, The Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

Shlomo Schwartzberg
Toronto, Canada

Lazy generalization
I have to express my dismay about the sweeping generalization cast upon the teaching profession by Siegrun Maybole (Letters, NI 366). I am a teacher and have never told a pupil that they were 'lazy, ignorant, stupid etc' and neither would the vast majority of my colleagues.

We work hard at a job many people do not care to do yet everybody has an opinion about. It is sometimes a thankless task when government officials decide to poke about in something they rarely know anything about.

In accusing teachers of being the main barrier to learning you are criticizing a worldwide profession whose intentions are to encourage everyone to achieve all that they are capable of.

Adam Sutcliffe
Shetland, Scotland

Winter veg
I was surprised to read the letter (NI 366) claiming that there are no local fruits and vegetables in winter in Winnipeg. This is a falsehood perpetuated by a profit-hungry food distribution system that insists on trucking food as far as possible before it is bought. I suggest that the writer please seek out local farmers (like my brother) who grow root vegetables and fruits that store well. (As a former Manitoban, I dearly miss Saskatoons!)

Yes it is sad that Coca-Cola is cheaper than milk for northern Canadians, especially since the sugar was probably shipped farther than the milk was! Again, our media/ culture has duped us. Instead of drinking Florida orange juice, we make and bottle our own sumac juice for the winter: local, nutritious and free!

Timothy Dyck
Durham, Canada

Homeopathic dupes
Re Gurmej Virk's letter (NI 366). 'Our populations are unhealthier than ever and the diseases that plague us are more serious' compared to 100 years ago? Really? When one in every three children born died of disease in childhood?

Big Pharma would love an effective medicine that could be produced for next to nothing; it would greatly increase profit margins. Homeopathy is 'discredited', by health departments, doctors and scientists, not because of any opposition by Big Pharma, but because there has never been any evidence that it has 'cured' anything. Yet charlatans continue to profit from selling it. Yes, you did leave something out of your Big Pharma issue (NI 362) - the massive profits Big (and Small) Pharma makes from the unregulated sale of homeopathic and other 'alternative' medicine which does no good and much harm.

Peter Kennedy pharmacist,
Sydney, Australia

A modest proposal
Congratulations on Adam Ma'anit's 'Imagine That!' article (More World, Less Bank, NI 365). Allow me to append a suggestion: People through a World Social Forum (WSF) should not only decommission the IMF/ World Bank and cancel all debts, personal, corporate and national, but investigate ways to replace our troublesome money economy with a social economy.

Let me suggest that this WSF should mandate all computer manufacturers along with their software companies, all producers of munitions and war machines, as well as production of all minerals and other raw materials. These form the basis for a new social economy and should be publicly controlled.

Is it at all possible to imagine this: a care and share economy?

Ken Muma
London, Canada

Lithuania on the up
The reports in West goes East (NI 366) covered some of the worst countries in Eastern Europe and reflect the dismal state of conditions that I have met in my travels in these sad places. But the issue tended to give the impression that the whole region is a failure. I have lived and worked in Lithuania since 1991 and the progress in the Baltic States is miraculous. After independence little happened for three years. Then we had a period of cosmetic improvement, but during the last five years development has been really solid. Lithuania has a growth rate of about 7 per cent, pollution is well under control, old towns are being beautifully restored and new supermarkets, shops and restaurants open daily. Taxes are being effectively collected and corruption is greatly reduced. Average salaries are about 30 Euros a day and morale is steadily rising.

Roderick Tuck
Kaunas, Lithuania.

HAVE YOUR SAY
If you have ideas for topics that you'd like to read about in the NI next year, why don't you let us know? Send your ideas to Dinyar Godrej by 21 June 2004, email: dinyar@antenna.nl

Wage gap
The recent Equality issue (NI 364) told us how women in Australia earn on average 30 per cent less than men (Facts). The average wage gap tells us very little, for it fails to take into account important factors such as age, education, consecutive years of experience, and type of job. When these factors are considered, women and men in Australia earn about the same (of course there is much to be done to redress the appalling inequalities around the globe). Interestingly you neglected to mention that in every country except Bangladesh, men's life expectancy is considerably less than women's (in Australia by 6 years). I suspect most men would happily take a 30-per-cent pay cut in order to live 6 years longer!

Greg Andresen
Henley Beach, Australia

Phony co-ops
Your article 'Sugar daddies' (The sugar trap, NI 363) on how sugarcane production has fuelled political corruption in some states of India left a sour taste. To me these are phony co-operatives and they bring shame on the international co-operative community. A true co-operative is guided by basic principles. The first principle, clearly breached in the Ambejogai cooperative, refers to open and voluntary membership - a co-operative is open to all, regardless of political affiliation, and should not be used as a political fiefdom. Second, democratic ownership and control should be in the hands of the members, not one family. Third, economic participation - members should benefit economically and this was clearly not the case for Uttam Siserao, who worked for free in the 2001-02 season. Finally a cooperative should be autonomous - and not run by politicians or 'those who have no stake in it at all'. Has the International Co-operative Alliance (www.ica.coop) no power or influence over these so-called co-operatives?

Kate Whittle
Shrewsbury, England

WOMEN'S RIGHTS
The NI is doing a magazine on women's rights which will look at what has changed for women since the UN Conference on women in Beijing in 1995. We are seeking short comments, thoughts and ideas from readers - both male and female - about the changes there have been and what still needs to happen. Please email: nikkivdg@newint.org by 31 July 2004.

Letter from Lebanon

Worlds of words
Reem Haddad on a beautiful bewilderment.

MUCH of the time I don't know what people are saying to me. I respond with a smile, a murmur, an unintelligible answer, and hope that I appear all-knowing. The Lebanese are fond of using proverbs to express their feelings - according to a Lebanese researcher, we have over 4,000 proverbs. Most of them rhyme and are quite pleasing to the ear. I confess, however, that it takes me some time to decipher them.

'If you are afraid, don't speak. But if you speak, don't be afraid,' I was told when I entered the field of journalism.

During interviews, I would often find myself on the threshold of a small house in a poverty-stricken area wondering whether my photographer and I would find a place to sit in the family home. But the welcome was always the same: 'If our houses are too small to receive you, our hearts will do so.'

My father has absolutely no luck in business ventures. When he bought some real estate, the Lebanese civil war erupted and the land became worthless. When he invested some money in stock, the market crashed. 'If he should go to sea,' my mother is fond of saying, 'the sea would dry up.'

My mother seems to understand the world of proverbs. 'He who gossips with you will gossip about you,' she would say sternly to me when a friend came over with an exciting piece of news.

She strongly believed in family unity. My two sisters and I grew up listening to her favourite proverb. 'You and your sister against your cousin,' she would repeat when refereeing fights between us and friends. 'And you and your cousin against the stranger.'

At times when I stubbornly refused to comply with her wishes, she would patiently say: 'He who doesn't agree with you, try to agree with him.'

And when I suspected a neighbour of swiping one of my toys, my mother was quick to advise: 'Shut your door rather than accuse your neighbour.'

At times I resorted to proverbs myself. A favourite proverb that I used frequently as a child to lord it over the neighbour's younger kids goes: 'She who is one day older than you, has one year more experience than you do.' And with that I was deemed worthy of making up the rules of our games.

During my wedding reception, a guest studied my husband. 'He seems a good man,' she whispered to me. 'Put your hands in cold water.' In other words, rest assured.

As my parents bade me goodbye at the end of the reception, I must have looked rather forlorn, for the same guest approached me again. 'Remember,' she said, 'the home which reared me doesn't forget me.'

In many ways, Lebanon remains a traditional country, especially with regard to women. Virginity is prized. In fact, men prefer to marry a woman whom 'no-one has kissed on her mouth but her mother.' Many parents are eager to marry off their daughters as 'a girl's marriage is her protection.'

And so it goes.

A man is 'well fed from his mother's milk' if he is strong and healthy.

A person who takes 'one step forward and two steps back' is hesitant.

And a person 'above the wind' is rich and prosperous.

Young people are told: 'Lying will get you lunch but not supper' - meaning a liar is shortly discovered.

Up-and-coming career persons are warned that 'there is not a tree which the wind cannot shake'.

The wealthy are reminded that 'money from earth remains on earth' - in other words, you can't take it with you once you're dead.

When someone suddenly reappears after a long absence, it is said that 'it has been a long, long time since this moon made its appearance.'

A proper Lebanese person would have a ready response, ideally another proverb. Unfortunately, words fail me in such situations. If my mother is nearby, she rises to the occasion as I stand there helplessly nodding. But my father - who like me gets lost in the world of proverbs - taught me a trick.

'Just say "May God bless you"' to everything,' he said. 'It gets you off the hook.'

I've tried it. And except for a few strange looks, it works most of the time.

I've also managed to memorize two or three proverbs. I am still waiting for an occasion to use them.

Reem Haddad works for the Daily Star in Beirut.

Previous page.
Choose another issue of NI.
Go to the contents page.
Go to the NI home page.
Next page.
© Copyright 2004 New Internationalist
Publications Ltd. All rights reserved.